Skip to main content

#13 A Manual for Cleaning Women (Lucia Berlin, 2015)

 Rating: 6/10

    Multiple industrial revolutions won't change how people of distinct echelons are treated differently. The juxtaposition of Maggie's life and the glimpses into the lives of rich people magnified the problematic distribution of advantage even during the third Industrial Revolution. While Maggie was trying to deal with the harsh realities of her fractured life (economically, mentally, etc.), she had to lower her self-respect and pride to blend in the capitalistic society. In Ms. Dr. Blum's house, Maggie's sullen attitude quickly turns into an understanding and respectful attitude the second she gets reminded of the fact that she's merely a cleaning lady.

    Personally, narrating style of this story was not favorable since I could find no solid development nor an incidental event. The story of a cleaning woman gazing out the bus window is prone to be monotonous if the reader finds it hard to realize her representation of overlooked working women. On the other hand, I liked how the author juxtaposed people of opposite lives, as it maximized the misery of cleaning women. I could temporarily sympathize with Maggie's helpless feelings when she was forced not to discipline kids in Dr. Blum's house. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Video Portfolio

<intro> : 14 sec Hi. My name is Nina Lee from Korean Minjok Leadership Academy. Wanna know more about me? I invite you to my library.  Each part of my bookshelf represents a chapter of my life.  Let’s look at this chapter.  <Chapter 1> : 25 sec I’ve been in love with books ever since I was young. It is pretty obvious as I made my own room into a library. Collecting, reading, the smell of faded paper, and even organizing them in bookshelves… I liked every part of it.  Books are like magical portals that let me become anything I imagine. But I didn’t want to stop just imagining. So, my life has been about becoming everything. <Chapter 2> : 30 sec  + surf I am a [sports]. Playing these sports as a sportswoman has shaped my resilience . I’ve learned that failure can never be an excuse for giving up. Failure, as well as success, is a melody that makes up a great musical composition.  <Chapter 3> : 20 sec Oh, speak...
Post a Comment
Read more

#8 The boarding house

    The boarding house, By James Joyce(1914) Rating: 8.2/10 There still exists an invisible social hierarchy that demarcates the level of individuals. Borderlines between each echelon are undefiable because they are preserved in an intangible and verbal way. It almost seems like modern citizens are solely focused on elevating class throughout their lives. Generally, it is considered successful when someone with a proletariat job marries another with a bourgeoisie job. Similarly, Ms.Mooney was affirmative that her daughter would have a happy life if she were committed to Mr.Doran.  In this flow, a sarcastic view towards the materialistic society stood out as a theme. Polly's innocent love was rather a cover for Ms.Mooney's unachieved goal of marrying "up." Mental paralysis of the Dubliners perhaps was another problem that Joyce was experiencing.  <The boarding house> approached as a relatable yet bittersweet story. Although it is unrightful to judge people with ...
Post a Comment
Read more

#22 My Wonderful Description of Flowers (Danielle Dutton)

 Rating: 6/10     Danielle Dutton's short story reminded me of " Cat Person" by Kristen Roupenian. In "Cat Person," a male character representing toxic masculinity develops an intimate relationship with an underage college student. When the girl starts rejecting him, he shows signs of obsession and eventually calls the girl a 'whore’. Similarly, in Danielle Dutton's story, a taste of feminism is foreshadowed by introducing a man who visits random houses and attempts to assault women. When the protagonist asserts that she doesn't recognize an unknown man who visited her home, the man gradually becomes impatient and turns out to be hostile. The two stories seemed similar in how women were victimized by male manipulations. (Although the severity of male manipulations differs at each level.)     Apart from Danielle Dutton's method of development   used in the story, this could have been more favorable for me. Although the story had a clear developmen...
Post a Comment
Read more